Skip to content
📦 Treat yourself to free shipping on all orders $80+
Best Sellers
New & Noteworthy
Trending
Snacks & Treats
Beverages
Pantry
Bakery
Pet
Dietary
🍷 Dry January
🎁 Gifts
All Natural Peanut Butter
Sort by:
Featured
Sort
Filter
Filters
Brand
B.T.R. Bar
(1)
Be Free Bar
(1)
Bhu Foods
(2)
Cocomo
(1)
Show more (13)
Category
Energy Bars
(5)
Energy Bars + Bites
(5)
Nut Butters
(13)
Pantry
(14)
Show more (6)
Company
BIPOC-Founded
(6)
Chef-Founded
(5)
Family-Founded
(6)
Male-Founded
(6)
Show more (2)
Enjoy For
Breakfast
(7)
Lunch
(8)
Post-Workout
(5)
Snacking
(24)
Show more (1)
Flavor Profile
Chocolatey
(5)
Salty
(7)
Savory
(9)
Sweet
(19)
Free / High / Low
Dairy-Free
(18)
Grain Free
(9)
High Protein
(8)
Low Sugar
(7)
Show more (4)
Good For
Diabetes
(5)
Energy
(14)
Kid Friendly
(6)
Muscle Build
(9)
Show more (1)
Impact
Eco-Friendly Packaging
(7)
Sustainable Practices
(7)
Lifestyle
Gluten-Free
(24)
Keto
(12)
Paleo
(5)
Plant-Based
(22)
Show more (2)
Add
B.T.R. Bar
4.7
(3)
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Adaptogenic Protein Bar (Pack)
$32.99
Add
One Trick Pony
5.0
(2)
One Trick Pony - Kinda Crunchy Peanut Butter (3-pack)
$34.50
Sale
Add
RUANI
5.0
(2)
Peanut Butter Brownie - Functional Snack
$22.79
$23.99
Add
One Trick Pony
One Trick Pony - Silky Smooth Peanut Butter (3-pack)
$34.50
Sale
Add
Hardcore Peanut Butter Spread Co.
4.9
(16)
Hardcore Superfood Peanut Butter with Blueberries | Smooth
$9.99
$15.99
Add
Bhu Foods
5.0
(1)
Refrigerated Protein Bar - Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
$28.74
Add
Elemental Superfood
Dark Chocolate + Peanut Butter Seedbar (12-pack)
$39.75
Add
One Trick Pony
One Trick Pony - Organic Peanut Butter Variety (3-pack)
$34.50
Add
Whims
2.0
(1)
WHIMS - Oat Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups (Pack)
$39.95
Add
One Trick Pony
One Trick Pony - Unsalted Smooth Peanut Butter (3-pack)
$34.50
Sale
Add
Hardcore Peanut Butter Spread Co.
5.0
(2)
Hardcore Superfood Peanut Butter with Blueberries | Coffee
$9.99
$13.99
Add
Nutty Novelties
Classic Peanut Butter (salted, smooth)
$8.49
Add
Skout Organic
Organic Kids Snack Bar - Chocolate Peanut Butter (Pack)
$7.99
Add
Nutty Novelties
5.0
(1)
Pure Crunchy Peanut Butter (unsalted)
$8.49
Add
Skout Organic
5.0
(1)
Organic Plant-Based Protein Bar - Peanut Butter (Pack)
$35.99
Sale
Add
Bhu Foods
5.0
(1)
Low Sugar, Vegan Protein Bar - Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
$28.97
$32.19
Sale
Add
Hardcore Peanut Butter Spread Co.
5.0
(1)
Hardcore Superfood Peanut Butter with Blueberries | Bourbon
$9.99
$11.99
Add
Winnie Lou - The Canine Co.
5.0
(2)
Dog - Peanut Butter Pretzel Treats
$7.99
Add
Nutty Novelties
5.0
(1)
Pure Peanut Butter (unsalted, smooth)
$8.49
Add
Nutty Novelties
Classic Crunchy Peanut Butter (salted)
$8.49
Add
E3 Energy Cubes
Peanut Butter & Chocolate E3 Energy Cubes (12-pack)
$39.96
Add
Cocomo
Cocomo Coconut Peanut Butter Travel Packs
$15
Add
Skout Organic
Organic Kids Snack Bar - Peanut Butter and Jelly (Pack)
$7.99
Add
Be Free Bar
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Bars - Honey-Sweetened
$30.40
